Nobody at Old Trafford on Saturday 17 November 2001 thought they were watching an ending. Why would they? It was a routine home game against a Leicester side at the wrong end of the table, United won 2–0, and the second goal came five minutes after half-time when Gary Neville swung in a cross from the right and Dwight Yorke got his head to it. RTÉ’s report called it “a glancing header” and noted, almost in passing, that it was his opening goal of the season. BBC Sport went one better and pointed out that it was his first goal since April. In mid-November. For a man who had shared the Premier League Golden Boot two and a half years earlier.
That was it. That was the last one. MUFC Wiki’s match page logs it as his first goal of 2001–02 and his 66th for the club, and the record has nothing after it. He would play for United for another ten weeks, most of them on the bench, and leave the following summer for Blackburn, where his old mate Andy Cole was waiting. Twenty-five years on, the header against Leicester feels like one of those moments football only reveals afterwards: a door closing so quietly that nobody heard it go.
So this is the story of how the most joyful striker of the treble season ended up scoring his final United goal on an ordinary afternoon that most people only remember for Fabien Barthez cleaning his boots on the post.
The afternoon itself
Let’s start with Barthez, because everybody else did. United went into the game in a poor run. MUFC Wiki’s record of Yorke’s appearances shows the fortnight before: a 3–1 defeat at Liverpool on 4 November, then a 4–0 hammering at Arsenal in the League Cup the next night, with Yorke on the pitch for both. The BBC’s report on the Leicester game opens by observing that the keeper’s “eccentricities have cost his side dear in recent games”. It was not a calm time to be a Manchester United supporter, which tells you something about the standards of the age.
Ruud van Nistelrooy put United ahead after 20-odd minutes, heading in a David Beckham cross from six yards. A minute later Laurent Blanc brought down Trevor Benjamin and Leicester had a penalty. What happened next is the bit the afternoon is remembered for. According to the BBC, as Muzzy Izzet ran up, Barthez “was busy cleaning mud off his boots on the goalpost”. Izzet scored anyway. The referee, Andy D’Urso, ordered a retake. This time Barthez was paying attention, guessed right and palmed the ball onto the post. The away end, the BBC noted with some understatement, “were incensed at what they perceived as unsporting behaviour from the United keeper”.
Dave Bassett, Leicester’s manager, made a change at half-time and gave a debut at left-back to Alan Rogers, a new £400,000 signing. Within five minutes of the restart, Yorke had made it 2–0, putting Neville’s cross beyond Ian Walker. The MUFC Wiki timeline puts the goal at 50 minutes in front of 67,651 people. Afterwards Bassett, a man FBH will always have a soft spot for, managed to find the silver lining that only a manager in a relegation scrap can find in a 2–0 defeat at Old Trafford: “At least today we looked like we knew what we were doing and we didn’t look like a relegation side.”
The team sheet is worth a second look. United started with Barthez; Gary Neville, Wes Brown, Blanc and Denis Irwin; Beckham, Roy Keane, Paul Scholes and Ryan Giggs; and van Nistelrooy and Yorke up front. The substitutes, per the BBC, were Roy Carroll, Mikaël Silvestre, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, Quinton Fortune and Nicky Butt. Andy Cole is not on it. Two and a half years after the pair of them had walked through Europe together, Yorke was starting alongside the man who had replaced them both, and the partner whose name was once welded to his was nowhere to be seen.
There is one more detail that makes this a very Dwight Yorke way to sign off. Leicester were his favourite victims. MUFC Wiki’s opponent table has him scoring six goals in six games against them for United, and winning all six. That included a hat-trick at Filbert Street on 16 January 1999, in a 6–2 win. If you were going to pick a team to score your last goal for Manchester United against, you could hardly have picked better.
The record signing who made Tommy Docherty wrong
To understand why a single header in November matters, you have to go back to what Yorke was in the first place.
He was a boy from Canaan, Tobago, spotted by Graham Taylor on an Aston Villa tour of the Caribbean. Glenn Moore’s profile in The Independent on the day he signed for United records that Taylor bought him for £120,000 from St Clair’s in 1989, and that when he first arrived at Villa, Tommy Docherty offered the following scouting report: “If that lad makes a First Division footballer, my name’s Mao-Tse-Tung.” Moore also noted that Yorke’s childhood friend was Brian Lara. They both played a bit of cricket and a bit of football as boys, and Lara chose the bat. For a while it looked like the right call. Then Yorke went to Manchester United for £12.6 million.
The transfer itself was a saga. The Independent’s report of 21 August 1998 has Villa’s chairman Doug Ellis accusing United of “tapping up” the player and admitting that Villa had lost him mentally: “He was determined to get away.” John Gregory, Villa’s manager, had wanted £16 million and at one point wanted Andy Cole in part-exchange. The deal was done in time to beat UEFA’s midnight deadline for the Champions League, and it made Yorke United’s record signing, ahead of Jaap Stam, who had arrived from PSV two months earlier. Gregory did not take it well. As The Irish Times reported, he told the Sun: “Dwight Yorke came to see me two weeks ago to tell me he wanted to play for Manchester United and not Aston Villa. If I’d had a gun at the time I would have shot him.”
Yorke, for his part, sounded like a man who couldn’t quite believe it. “Coming from Tobago, which is such a small island where football comes second to cricket, it was a dream opportunity to play here,” he told The Independent. “Aston Villa gave me that chance and made me the player I am. I’ve got a new life now and I hope I can win some silverware here as well.”
Some silverware. Quite.
Calypso and Cole
The thing about Yorke and Cole is that they shouldn’t have worked. Cole had spent three and a half years at Old Trafford being picked apart for what he wasn’t, and Yorke had been bought partly because United had struggled to score against Arsenal, ŁKS Łódź and Leicester at the start of 1998–99, as Moore put it at the time. Instead, as FBH’s own long read on Andy Cole puts it, Yorke became “an instant best mate” rather than another rival for the shirt. They were inseparable on and off the pitch, and you could see the friendship in the football: the little give-and-goes, the dummies, the way one would peel off and the other would know exactly where to put it.
The evening that announced them to Europe was 25 November 1998 at the Camp Nou. BBC Sport’s report called them “the deadly duo”. Barcelona scored inside 49 seconds; Yorke lashed in an equaliser from the edge of the box after Jesper Blomqvist fed him; Yorke then turned creator, exchanging passes with Cole and putting him through for 2–1; and after Rivaldo’s free kick made it 2–2, Yorke headed United back in front, a few seconds after missing an almost identical chance. Rivaldo’s bicycle kick made it 3–3, which was a fair enough way to be denied. That autumn’s Barcelona games are a story in themselves on this site, including the home game one FBH contributor never quite made it to.
Then came the knockout rounds. In the quarter-final first leg against Inter at Old Trafford on 3 March 1999, Beckham crossed twice and Yorke headed in twice. The BBC called the crosses “inch-perfect” and noted that the second, in first-half injury time, was Yorke’s seventh goal in as many European games. In the semi-final second leg in Turin on 21 April, with United 2–0 down to Juventus after 11 minutes and Roy Keane’s header already on the board, Yorke equalised with a header from a Cole cross (BBC). The Guardian’s minute-by-minute had it as a diving header from a Beckham cross, which tells you how quickly memory starts to blur. Whoever crossed it, it was the goal that put United ahead on away goals. Minutes later Yorke hit the post. Near the end he ran through, was brought down by Angelo Peruzzi, and Cole followed up to roll in the third. That night is also the night Paul Scholes was booked and ruled out of the final, which FBH covered in yesterday’s Scholes piece.
By May it had become a treble. According to BBC Sport, Cole and Yorke scored 53 goals between them that season. Yorke’s 18 in the league tied him with Michael Owen and Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink for the Premier League Golden Boot. Ten years later, in a Guardian interview with Hannah Pool, he summed it up in a way that could only have come from him: “In the first we won the treble and I finished top scorer: I was walking on cloud nine.”
The smile was the thing. For a few years, Dwight Yorke looked like the happiest man ever to be paid to play football, and that is not a small achievement at a club run by Alex Ferguson.
The high-water mark, and the drift
The partnership didn’t end with the treble. Yorke kept scoring, and MUFC Wiki logs a hat-trick against Derby in March 2000 and another against Arsenal in February 2001. That last one deserves a paragraph to itself.
On 25 February 2001, United beat Arsenal 6–1 at Old Trafford to go 16 points clear at the top. The BBC described it as a “football masterclass”. Yorke scored inside two minutes after a quick exchange with Scholes, scored again when Gilles Grimandi’s hesitation played him onside from a Keane pass, and completed his hat-trick when Beckham dribbled out of a corner and hit a pass more than 40 yards to send him clean through. He then set up Keane for the fourth. By half-time it was 5–1, and some of the Arsenal supporters had started drifting away before the half was even over. All this on a day when Ferguson had left an in-form Teddy Sheringham on the bench.
It is the last truly great Dwight Yorke afternoon, and with hindsight it is a strange one, because by then the ground under him was already moving. The MUFC Wiki season table tells the story without adjectives. After 51 appearances in 1998–99 and 47 in 1999–2000, he played 38 times in 2000–01, 13 of them as a substitute. In 2001–02 he made 16 appearances, 10 of them from the bench, and scored once.
Yorke himself never pretended the drift was all someone else’s fault. “My first three years at United were pretty much flawless,” he told the Guardian in 2009. “But in the third year I took my eye off the football, things were happening off the pitch – everywhere I went the media was talking about me, and no one had taught me how to deal with those things. It took me a while to realise I’d done some wrong, and by the time I tried to change it around it was too late. Sir Alex Ferguson is quite intimidating; he can make your life very difficult.”
That is about as honest as a footballer’s memory gets. It also skips over the other half of the story, which is that Ferguson had already gone shopping.
The Dutchman who was worth waiting for
On 21 April 2000, the BBC reported that United had agreed a British record fee of £18.5 million with PSV Eindhoven for Ruud van Nistelrooy. The figure it smashed was United’s previous record, the £12.6 million they had paid Villa for Yorke. You don’t need to be a football romantic to see what that meant. Van Nistelrooy had top-scored in the Dutch league with 31 goals and said he hoped he could cement a place in the first team. Then he did his knee, and the deal had to wait.
When it finally came through, the message got louder. John May’s piece for BBC Sport in July 2002 said the signing “boomed out a message to the Old Trafford strike collective”, one that was reinforced by the fact that Ferguson “was prepared to wait a year for the Dutchman following a serious knee injury”. May’s line on what came next is the best summary anyone has written of the end of Cole and Yorke at United: “Doomed men, they say, do not hear the bell that tolls for them, and van Nistelrooy’s electric first season, plus the consistent goalscoring of Ole-Gunnar Solskjaer meant that Cole and Yorke were no longer the chosen pair.”
You can watch it happening in the autumn of 2001. On 3 September, the Guardian reported, Yorke turned up almost an hour late for training and was threatened with disciplinary action. Ferguson tried to play it down in public, and his words are worth quoting in full because they are so perfectly Fergie: “It is one of Dwight’s idiosyncrasies. He just forgets the time,” he said. “He thought that because it was international week and there were only a few players in he would come in when he felt like it. I explained that timekeeping is important at this club. I don’t accept him being late and he accepts that. But it is not going to threaten his position here. He has done very well all season and he will continue to be in my plans.”
That Saturday, Cole and Yorke started together in a 4–1 win over Everton, and then both found themselves on the bench for the Champions League opener at Olympiakos. Ferguson’s explanation, reported by The Irish Times, was polite, tactical and quietly devastating: “Andy and Dwight both worked very hard. It gave me a chance to let them know we still think highly of them. But I have tried a system which I think may suit us in Europe on some occasions. That is with Van Nistelrooy on his own and Scholesy in behind.”
One up front. In other words, no room for a partnership at all.
By the end of September, Yorke had made two Premier League appearances, one of them as a substitute, and had a thigh problem that kept him off the plane for the Champions League game against Deportivo. He told MUTV, as RTÉ reported, what any striker in that position would tell you: “You come in for one game, then find yourself sitting on the bench again. From my experience you need to play three, four or five games to get any momentum. If you haven’t done well, then you can start to think if you have done something wrong. It is frustrating, but I presume Andy Cole and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer feel the same. We just want a chance to play.”
So when he started against Leicester seven weeks later and scored, it was not the comeback of a forgotten man. It was a striker who had been given a game and taken his chance, and it changed nothing.
Ten more weeks
What happened after Leicester is all there in the appearance log, and it’s a bit sad to read. MUFC Wiki has him on as a substitute in the 1–1 draw at Bayern Munich three days later, and again in the 3–1 defeat at Arsenal on 25 November. He started the 3–0 win over Boavista in the Champions League on 5 December and the 1–0 home defeat by West Ham three days after that. Then there were substitute appearances against Derby on 12 December and Newcastle on 2 January. He didn’t score in any of them.
In between, his partner left. On 29 December 2001 Andy Cole joined Blackburn for £7.6 million, and his words to the press, reported in the Guardian, could have been Yorke’s: “I could have stayed at Old Trafford and been a squad player at the best club in the world, but football means more to me than sitting on the bench.” The man who had signed him was Graeme Souness. Remember that name.
The last game was at the Riverside on 26 January 2002, an FA Cup fourth-round tie against Middlesbrough. MUFC Wiki’s match page has Yorke coming on for Solskjaer in the 80th minute. Five minutes later Noel Whelan scored, Andy Campbell added a second in the 89th, and United were out of the Cup. That was the last competitive appearance Dwight Yorke made for Manchester United: ten minutes as a substitute in a defeat at Middlesbrough. The treble was less than three years old.
Re-United
He was a Manchester United player for six more months, at least on paper. When he finally went, BBC Sport reported on 26 July 2002 that Ferguson “has been looking to offload him for about a year and did not allocate him a squad number for next season”. United had wanted £6 million. Blackburn paid £2 million, rising to £2.6 million depending on appearances and team performance. The Guardian’s report that day opened with the line that he had “ended 12 months of warming the bench at Manchester United”, and pointed out that United had lost more than £10 million on him. He had a year left on his contract, and the club wanted to sell now rather than lose him for nothing.
Souness, who now had both halves of the partnership, was delighted. “Dwight is a player I have targeted for some time and it is tremendous news he has signed for us,” he told the BBC. Yorke sounded relieved more than anything: “I can’t tell you how delighted I am to sign for Blackburn and get this great opportunity. There’s a passion deep inside me that wants to do well and I’m desperate to re-establish myself in the Premiership. I had a fantastic few years at United, but it’s been frustrating of late and coming to Blackburn just feels right.”
He was candid about why Blackburn, too. “Everyone knows I’m a pal of Andy Cole,” he said, “but he’s not the only player I’m familiar with in the squad and I’m looking forward to playing alongside them all.”
John May at the BBC could not resist the pop reference, and nor, frankly, can we. “Peaches and Herb’s biggest hit might have been written with Dwight Yorke and Andy Cole in mind,” he wrote, before adding a warning that time would partly prove right: “as any soul duo may confirm, love is not always better the second time around.” Within a couple of weeks they were scoring together again in a pre-season friendly, christening Blackpool’s revamped ground in a 4–2 win, with Cole getting two and Yorke finishing off a move between them with a shot into the roof of the net. “I think you saw glimpses of what Yorke and Cole will do this year,” said Souness. “I don’t think it’s a surprise to anyone, is it?” As the FBH Cole piece notes, both of them finished that first season at Ewood Park on 13 goals in 43 games, and Rovers finished sixth. It wasn’t 1999, but it was something.
What the header tells us
There is a temptation, with a quarter-century anniversary, to make a single goal carry more weight than it can bear. The header against Leicester was not a farewell. Nobody waved, and there was no reason for anyone in the ground to think it was the last one.
But it works as a full stop, and the sentence before it is worth reading again. A striker bought for a record fee, from a club whose manager wanted to shoot him for leaving, became half of the most fun strike partnership the Premier League had seen. He scored at the Camp Nou, against Inter, in Turin. He shared a Golden Boot. He had a hat-trick against Arsenal before the game was 25 minutes old. And then, in the space of about 18 months, he was squeezed out by a British record signing, by his own admitted lapses, by a manager whose patience was legendary in the wrong direction, and by the plain fact that Ferguson had decided the next United would play with one up front. One header in November, and then nothing.
Yorke has never sounded bitter about it, which is part of why people still like him so much. “I’ve been back to United numerous times since I left and things between me and Fergie are fine,” he told the Guardian’s Sachin Nakrani in 2010. He also remembered what Ferguson said when he left: “Things haven’t worked out for you here but what you have done for this club will never be forgotten.” Yorke’s own verdict: “That was phenomenal given what happened.”
He didn’t pretend to be sorry, either. “In hindsight I could have done things differently,” he said in the same interview. “But would I give up the women and nights out for another year at United? Would that make me happy? Would that make me the person I am today? I’m not sure. I have no regrets. I went to United to win things and I achieved that.”
Years later, when it looked as though the man who replaced him was heading out of Old Trafford too, Yorke offered van Nistelrooy some advice via Sky Sports that was really a summary of his own last season: “I don’t think there is any way back if you fall out with the manager. He is a very strong manager who always does what he thinks is best for Manchester United and that is the most important thing to him.”
He was right, of course. He usually was about Ferguson, once he’d had time to think it over. But if you’re looking for the right way to remember Dwight Yorke at Manchester United, it probably isn’t the ten minutes at the Riverside or the year on the bench. It’s 66 goals in 152 games, a smile you could see from the top of the Stretford End, and a last goal that was a header from a Gary Neville cross against the team he scored against more than anyone, on a November afternoon when nobody was paying attention, because the goalkeeper was busy cleaning his boots.