Eighty-eight years ago today, a Second Division inside-forward from Newark scored five times for England at Old Trafford, three of them in the time it takes to boil a kettle. What came after was harder, and he met it better than anyone had a right to expect.
On the red-brick wall of Lovers Lane Primary School in Newark there is a small maroon plaque, put up in 2013, with the three lions in one corner and a cockerel on a ball in the other. It says George William “Willie” Hall, Tottenham Hotspur and England forward, was born near here and attended this school, and that he is the “holder of the world record for the quickest hat-trick in international football”. The photograph of it on Geograph, taken by a contributor called El Loco in 2021, is the one behind the print at the top of this page. Its caption is a little more careful than the plaque. It calls Hall the man “who scored the then fastest hat-trick in international football”.
That word “then” is doing a lot of work, and so is everything else about the afternoon of Wednesday 16 November 1938. Nobody seems to agree exactly how long the hat-trick took. The plaque says it is a world record and Tottenham’s own Hall of Fame says the world record went in 2000. The number that gets passed around on anniversaries like this one, three minutes and thirty seconds, is the one the record books like best, but it isn’t the one every record book uses.
What everybody agrees on is that Willie Hall scored five goals in a 7-0 win over Ireland, that he cried in the dressing room afterwards, and that eight years later he had lost both legs. The record is the reason people remember him. It is also, I think, the least interesting thing about him.
Ransome and Marles, and the extra £500
He was born on 12 March 1912 at 12 Tenter Buildings, Appletongate, in Newark, into a very large family. England Football Online’s player profile, which draws on Douglas Lamming’s An English Football Internationalists’ Who’s Who, counts eleven older brothers and sisters. He played for his school and for Nottinghamshire schools, then for Newark YMCA, starting in their reserves, and then for the works team at Ransome and Marles, the bearings company. A 2012 Nottingham Evening Post piece by Ray Yeomans, reprinted on the Big Red Book site, says Ransome and Marles won the Notts Alliance in 1929-30 with Hall in the side, and that his brothers Cyril and Harry played too.
Notts County persuaded him to turn professional on 18 November 1930. They were in the Third Division (South), and Tottenham’s Hall of Fame entry notes that he made his debut in the last match of the season in which County won it. He played around 35 games for them over two years. Then, in December 1932, somebody at Tottenham broke a leg.
The somebody was George Greenfield, an inside-forward whom Spurs’ own history describes as a schemer of rare talent. In the dozen matches before he broke his leg at Fulham, Tottenham had scored 42 goals. Spurs were in the Second Division, they were in a promotion race and they had just lost the man making the team work. The manager, Percy Smith, went straight to Meadow Lane for the one inside-forward “rated every bit as exciting a prospect”, a 20-year-old called Willie Hall.
The fee depends on which book you open. England Football Online says £2,500, while The Daisy Cutter’s 2013 anniversary piece and the Nottingham Evening Post both say £2,600. Everybody agrees about the add-on, which was another £500 if he played for England. Tottenham’s Hall of Fame entry records, with what reads like a slight wince, that his first cap “meant we had to pay Notts County another £500”. Clauses like that were not the invention of the Premier League’s agents. Notts County were writing them while Herbert Chapman was still alive.
His Spurs debut, inevitably, was against Notts County, away, on Christmas Eve 1932. Spurs lost 3-0. Football has always enjoyed that kind of joke.
The link man
He was not, by any normal measure, a goalscorer, and that matters to the rest of the story. Spurs credit him with 27 league goals and two in the FA Cup in more than 220 senior peacetime matches. The Daisy Cutter points out that the five he scored for England on 16 November 1938 were more than half of what he scored for Spurs all that season.
What he did instead was what inside-forwards did before the word “midfielder” had been invented. The Spurs history says he provided “the perfect link between defence and attack”, always looking for the ball and quite happy to come back for it. He was particularly good with the flying winger Willie Evans, knowing exactly when to release him. He could also dribble “as good as any winger”. Tommy Lawton, who played alongside him for England, put it more bluntly in a line quoted by the Newark Advertiser in 2014: “Willie Hall was a ball player of the highest class. He could make a football do the most alarming tricks.”
Spurs went up as runners-up to Stoke at the end of 1932-33, and Hall went with them, from the Third Division to the First in a little over two years. A year after joining Tottenham he was an England player. His debut came on 6 December 1933 against France, at White Hart Lane, his own ground. England won 4-1, and then the selectors forgot about him for nearly four years.
Part of that was the selectors, who were a committee and behaved like one. Part of it was Manchester City. In November 1934, Spurs’ history says, three City players went in to tackle him at once, and he was left “crumpled on the ground” and needed a cartilage operation that kept him out for nearly five months. By the time he came back Spurs were all but relegated, and in 1935 they went down.
So for the rest of the 1930s Willie Hall was a Second Division footballer. That is worth keeping in mind for what follows. On the day he scored five times for England at Old Trafford, his club were playing their league football against the likes of Chesterfield.
Recalled from the Second Division
The selectors came back for him in October 1937, which tells you how good he must have been in Division Two. His second cap was in Belfast, a 5-1 win over Ireland in which he scored. Then he scored again against Wales at Ayresome Park in a 2-1 win. He played in the 5-4 win over Czechoslovakia at White Hart Lane and in the 1-0 defeat by Scotland at Wembley in April 1938.
England Football Online’s match list has one detail from that spring that it would be wrong to make too much of. On the summer tour of 1938 he was listed for the match against Germany in Berlin as an injured reserve, so he was not on the pitch that day. In October 1938 he was back for the match at Highbury against a Rest of Europe XI, which England won 3-0, and he scored. That made him the obvious inside-right when the selectors met after the Norway game on 9 November to pick the side for Old Trafford a week later.
The inside-left place caused the fuss that week, and Hall’s got none. The selectors dropped Derby’s Ronnie Dix, who had been scoring freely, and picked Eric Stephenson of Leeds, who had only just come back from a broken toe. England Football Online reproduces a round-up from the Derby Evening Telegraph of 10 November, in which the Telegraph’s man called it “bordering on the ridiculous” and quoted half of Fleet Street agreeing with him. “What do the Selectors want?” he asked, a sentence that could have run in any English newspaper in any decade since.
Wednesday afternoon at Old Trafford
Kick-off was at 2.30pm on a Wednesday. The FA Cup first-round draw was made before the match, which tells you something about how a midweek international was staged in 1938. England Football Online records an attendance of 40,386 and receipts of £3,305 2s. Ireland won the toss.
It is worth being clear about the opposition, because the X post that set this piece going, like a lot of things written since, calls them Northern Ireland. In 1938 the team picked by the Irish FA in Belfast was still simply “Ireland”, and on this occasion, for the first time, every one of its players came from an English club. Peter Doherty of Manchester City was at inside-left, and the Everton full-back Billy Cook was captain. In goal was Jim Twomey of Leeds, and he only played because Manchester United’s Tommy Breen, who had been picked, couldn’t. Twomey was told on 10 November. He was winning his second cap, and it was not going to be a good afternoon to win it.
England lined up in the 2-3-5 of the time. Vic Woodley was in goal, Eddie Hapgood captained the side from left-back, and Stan Cullis and a debutant called Joe Mercer were in the half-back line. The forward line was Matthews, Hall, Lawton, Stephenson and Smith. Tommy Lawton was nineteen. Stanley Matthews, who FBH has written about at length, was twenty-three and already the most famous footballer in the country.
England scored after eight minutes. The Times report, reproduced by England Football Online and by the England International Database, describes a move that started in the English goalmouth. Ken Willingham pushed the ball through to Matthews, Matthews turned in and gave Lawton a through pass, and Lawton “consumated it with a drive that gave Twoomey no sort of chance”. The spelling of both words is The Times‘s, not mine.
Then, for nearly half an hour, nothing much happened. Then everything did.
Three goals, and the argument about the clock
According to The Times, Hall’s first goal “seemed unnecessary”. Matthews put over a centre “which looked innocent enough, but the Irish defence faltered and Hall was able to shoot through”. “Almost immediately after the kick-off Hall scored again, this time from the inside-left position. His shot went low into the corner of the net, and immediately afterwards came another goal. The ball came from the left, Twoomey came out, and before he was properly back and on his balance Hall had taken his third chance.”
You’ll notice that The Times doesn’t give a time. Everyone else does, and they disagree.
The England International Database puts the goals at 36, 38 and 40 minutes, and its note on the match calls it “4 minutes between first and third goals which is still an international record”. England Football Online’s version of the same match puts them at 35, 37 and 38. Its team notes call it a hat-trick “in three minutes” and say it is the international record for fast scoring. The Daisy Cutter uses the 36-38-40 minutes and then says the feat was “timed officially at 3 minutes 30 seconds”. The Newark Advertiser goes with “a 3½-minute hat-trick”. Tottenham’s own site has had it both ways: “the space of four minutes” in a 2013 anniversary piece, and “just under four minutes” in another a few months later.
I don’t think anyone is wrong, exactly. In 1938 nobody in the press box was working with a stopwatch accurate to the second, and the match minute is a blunt instrument when three goals land so close together. Where a “3 minutes 30 seconds” timing comes from, and who timed it officially, I haven’t been able to find in any source I could read. So the honest version is this: somewhere between three and four minutes, with three and a half the figure that has stuck.
The bigger claim needs the same care. The record books I read agree that it is still the quickest hat-trick by an England player. The England International Database says so, Tottenham said so on the 75th anniversary, and nothing I could find has bettered it. The world record is a different matter. The Newark plaque calls him the holder of the world record for international football, and the Big Red Book’s summary of his This Is Your Life calls it “the fastest hat-trick ever recorded in an international game”. But Tottenham’s own Hall of Fame says it was “a record that stood until broken in 2000”, and the Geograph caption’s “then” points the same way. I’m happy to call it England’s quickest. I wouldn’t put a plaque up saying it’s the world’s any more.
Five, and a man with his back to goal
Half-time came at 4-0. Just before it, England Football Online records, Ireland’s outside-left Jackie Brown collided with Billy Morris, who was making his England debut at right-back. Brown was carried off with a leg injury and came back for the second half “limping badly”. It was a long time before substitutes, and the Irish were down to ten fit men and a passenger.
Hall, says The Times, “might have scored yet another before half-time, but even as it was he had only to wait for 10 minutes afterwards”. His fourth goal is the one I’d most like to have seen. “Matthews put the ball into the centre, and somehow or other Hall managed with his back to the goal to hook an awkwardly bouncing ball high into the net – an incredible goal.” England Football Online, working from other reports, calls it an overhead kick. The fifth came ten minutes later: “A dribble by Matthews which beat two men and a perfect flick of a pass paved the way.”
Late on, Matthews scored himself. The Times says it was four minutes from the end and the record books put it on 75 minutes, which is the clock problem again. He ran from the halfway line, “did the one thing an anxious defender did not want him to do, and shot through from an angle which looked impossibly acute”. England won 7-0. In the last five minutes Stan Cullis was hurt and finished the match at outside-left, which is a sentence that would get you a long way in a 1938 pub quiz.
Here is the line from The Times that I think tells you most about the day, and about Hall: “Five of these seven goals were scored by Hall, and that feat in itself would seem to indicate that Hall was the hero of the match. As it happened the man who did more than anyone else to win the game for England was Matthews.”
That is not as unkind as it looks. The England International Database credits Matthews with the assist for three of Hall’s five, and the Daisy Cutter goes further and says he was credited with all of them. Hall had done what inside-forwards did in a 2-3-5: he stood where Matthews needed him to be and he finished what Matthews started. It is a reminder that the most famous scoring feat of his career came from a player who made his living setting things up for other people. For one afternoon the arrangement ran the other way.
Crying in the dressing room
The best source on how Hall felt about it is the man who made most of the goals. Matthews wrote about it in his autobiography, The Way It Was. The passage quoted by the Daisy Cutter reads: “Willie was full of emotion back in the dressing room and cried unashamedly as each of his team-mates in turn congratulated him on his outstanding performance and his England goalscoring match record.”
Then there’s the line from the same book that everyone who writes about Hall ends up using, because nobody has put it better: “He was the most unassuming of men, modest to a fault. His unselfish play and great contribution to a game was never truly appreciated by the sports writers of the day.”
The record he equalled is worth getting right as well. Tottenham’s 75th anniversary piece lists the men who have scored five in a match for England: Howard Vaughton of Aston Villa against Ireland in 1882, Steve Bloomer of Derby against Wales in 1896, Hall in 1938, and Malcolm Macdonald against Cyprus in 1975. Hall was the first to do it in the twentieth century. Nobody has done it since Supermac, which is a statistic that tells you something about the Cyprus defence of 1975 and something about the rest of international football since. England Football Online adds one more nice footnote. Five for England equalled Hughie Gallacher’s five for Scotland against Ireland in 1929, but the overall international record still belonged to an Irishman, Joe Bambrick, who had scored six against Wales in 1930. Ireland went home from Old Trafford beaten 7-0, but at least one record was still theirs.
Spurs were proud enough to say so in print. The programme for the next home game, a reserve fixture on 19 November, carried a column headed “Willie Hall’s Great Achievement”. It ended, Tottenham recorded in 2013, like this: “Hall, we salute you! You have made football history, and in doing so you have brought renown to the football of the country, and you have enormously enhanced your own reputation.” A cartoon of his five goals went on the cover of the programme for the league game against Chesterfield a week later. That’s Second Division Spurs, saluting their England record-breaker in the club programme. Every bit of that is very 1938.
The last of the summer tours
He won three more caps. He played at Hampden in April 1939, when England won 2-1, and then went on the summer tour. In Milan, at San Siro, he scored in a 2-2 draw with Italy. His last cap was against Yugoslavia in Belgrade on 18 May 1939, a 2-1 defeat. The England International Database puts his final record at ten caps and nine goals. England Football Online has him as England’s top scorer for both 1938 and 1938-39. Seven of the nine came in the Home Championship, five of them in one afternoon.
Then the war came, and his career turned out to be over at 27, although nobody knew it yet. He wasn’t taken by the forces. Tottenham’s history says he was rejected because of injuries he had picked up playing football, and he served in the police war reserve in London instead. That kept him available for Spurs’ wartime side, and he played for it constantly. “In the early years of the War he was the most regular performer,” the Hall of Fame entry says, “playing week in, week out in whatever position needed filling, often full-back.” The Daisy Cutter says he captained the side. In January 1943 he guested for Northampton Town, and he turned out for a Combined Civil Defence side and the RAF that year.
In 1940 he married Lilian Jefferies in Barking. England Football Online notes she was a milliner, and everybody called her Betty. That turns out to matter later.
“No more football for Willie Hall”
The trouble started with what sounded like nothing. “The trouble all started through pulling a muscle,” the Essex Chronicle wrote in December 1945, but it wasn’t a muscle for long. Tottenham’s history says that late in 1943 he was “struck down by a serious leg disease”, and in February 1944 he retired. A month later the People told its readers: “No more football for Willie Hall. The doctors say his injured right ankle cannot be healed and he must not attempt to kick a ball again. So fair-haired Willie, one of the finest inside-rights the game has ever seen and one of Tottenham’s most popular players, leaves the field and is now hoping for a managerial post.”
He got one. On 26 September 1945 Clapton Orient, as they then were, appointed him manager. The 2012 Nottingham Evening Post piece says he was the youngest manager in the Football League at the time. It was the first season after the war, the autumn Dynamo Moscow came to Britain and the whole country seemed to want to be in a football ground.
It lasted ten weeks. On 7 December he resigned because of illness. The press clippings collected by England Football Online are short, and that makes them hard to read. On 21 December 1945 the Essex Chronicle reported: “It is sad to see Willie Hall, the England and Tottenham Hotspur star forward, hobbling about on the Chelmsford City ground on Saturday. He came over with the Clapton Orient players. His left leg is in such a bad state that it is almost certain to be amputated.”
The diagnosis was thrombosis. On 8 February 1946 the Daily Herald reported a dance held at Tottenham to raise money for him while he was in hospital. Len Goulden of Chelsea and England came with his arm still in a sling, and an autographed football fetched £50. In March the Sunderland Echo reported that London surgeons were “fighting to prevent Willie Hall from having to lose his leg above the knee”. They had operated on the nerves of his back to try to improve the blood supply, in the hope that if the leg had to come off, it could come off lower down. On 28 March the Nottingham Evening Post reported that his right leg had been amputated below the knee that day.
Then, on 6 May 1947, the Nottingham Journal ran the headline “WILLIE HALL NOW LEGLESS”, over one line saying that his remaining leg, the left, had been amputated. The headline is cruel, and it was the period’s style. The dates themselves are not quite settled. The Big Red Book’s programme notes put the right leg in 1945 and the left in 1946, but I’ve followed the newspaper reports, which are dated. Either way, within three and a half years of retiring, the man Tommy Lawton said could make a football do the most alarming tricks had lost the lower parts of both his legs. Lawton wrote about it in My Twenty Years of Soccer, in a passage quoted by the Daisy Cutter: “What a tragedy it was that Willie should lose both his precious legs, the legs that had thrilled us all in football for many a year.”
30,220 at White Hart Lane
Football did, for once, look after one of its own. Tottenham gave him a benefit match against an FA XI at White Hart Lane on 7 May 1946. The Newark Advertiser says he was the first Spurs player to be given one, and that it drew 30,220 people and raised more than £3,000. Tottenham’s own account gives the same crowd. Notts County staged another for him.
There was a third, of a sort. England Football Online notes that an international trial match on 18 September 1946 doubled as a benefit for Hall. The Big Red Book reprint of the Nottingham Evening Post piece lists the teams. Nottingham Forest’s manager Billy Walker put out a Combined XI against an FA XI with Frank Swift in goal, Billy Wright and Stan Cullis at the back, and Tom Finney, Wilf Mannion, Albert Stubbins, Raich Carter and Jimmy Mullen up front. It finished 2-2. If you want a measure of what English football thought of Willie Hall, that FA XI will do.
He didn’t leave the game straight away. Tottenham’s history says that “despite the disability, he remained in football for several years as a coach and manager with Clapton Orient, Chelmsford City and Chingford Town”, and that he was vice-president of the Spurs Supporters’ Club for many years. Lamming’s Who’s Who, quoted by England Football Online, has him as licensee of a pub called The Archers in Osborne Street, in the East End, and as a partner with his old Spurs team-mate Vic Buckingham in a sports outfitters at Gants Hill. Buckingham later managed Ajax and Barcelona, which makes it a better shop to have owned a share in than most. In December 1950 the Nottingham Journal reported another operation, this time on his right shoulder.
The stage door at the BBC Television Theatre
On Monday 16 February 1959, Willie Hall was taken to the BBC Television Theatre by the sports editor Paul Fox. The Big Red Book, the archive of This Is Your Life, says he had been “led to believe he was there to see some film in which he appears”. At the stage door he met Eamonn Andrews and the red book.
It went out live from 7.30 to 8pm. The guest list survives. Betty was there, and so was Vic Buckingham. Stanley Matthews came too, still playing for Blackpool at 44. Most of the other names are people only Hall’s family will know now, which is what made the programme work. The Daisy Cutter quotes the inscription inside the book: “Willie Hall – football genius and true gentleman, your brand of unique courage has inspired all who have known you. Your kindness and humour have brought solace into the lives of all you have met.”
Tottenham’s history says he was one of the first footballers ever given This Is Your Life. Fifteen years after he had stopped playing and twenty after his last cap, the BBC still thought a Wednesday afternoon at Old Trafford and the way he had dealt with what came after made a programme. They were right.
Back to Newark
The sources differ on when he went home. The Newark Advertiser says he left London and returned to Newark in 1954 to be near his sister, while the Big Red Book has 1954 as the year he became a publican in the East End. What they agree on is the ending. The Nottingham Evening Post piece says he died at his sister’s house in Newark, after a heart attack, “just days after watching his old side Spurs beat Chelsea in the FA Cup final”. Tottenham’s Hall of Fame gives the date as 22 May 1967. That was two days after Spurs had beaten Chelsea 2-1 at Wembley. He was 55.
England Football Online records a funeral at St Mary Magdalene in Newark and burial of his ashes in Newark Cemetery. That year Tottenham donated a trophy in his name to the newly formed Newark Alliance league, and it was played for for almost half a century. In 2014 the Alliance gave the original cup back to Spurs, to go on display at White Hart Lane and then in the museum at the new stadium. “He is the best player Newark has ever produced,” the Alliance’s Dennis Rawle told the club. The Spurs historian Andy Porter told the Newark Advertiser that “to students of Spurs’ history he was a star of our 1930s team”, and that his five against Ireland made him “unique among the England players listed on our international honours board”.
Then, in July 2013, came the plaque. England Football Online, quoting OurNottinghamshire, says it was unveiled by the mayor of Newark on the afternoon of Tuesday 23 July in the playground at Lovers Lane, the school where he had started out.
Better than you remember
I keep coming back to The Times. It said that Hall’s five goals “would seem to indicate that Hall was the hero of the match”, and then gently pointed out that the real hero was Matthews. That is fair as match reporting. As a summary of a life it’s wrong.
The hat-trick is a fine thing to have on a plaque, and I’d have it on mine. But the things that make Willie Hall worth writing about 88 years on are the ones a stopwatch can’t measure. He was a Second Division player picked for England on merit. He spent his career passing to wingers, and on the one day the wingers passed back he cried in front of his team-mates. He went to work in a police reserve uniform and played wherever Spurs needed him. He took a manager’s job while his legs were failing, and he turned up at Chelmsford with the Orient players when he could barely walk. He lost both legs before he was 36, and then he opened a shop, ran a pub, coached non-league sides and went back to White Hart Lane as a supporters’ club vice-president.
Our Dave Mackay piece was about one kind of Spurs hard man. Willie Hall was a different kind, small and fair-haired and modest to a fault, according to the best winger in the world. He was hard in the way that counts once football is over.
Three goals in three and a half minutes, or three, or four. Pick whichever book you like. What happened after is the part I’d put on the wall.