The Yellow submarine is still sinking


It’s a funny world. Just three months after sacking Javi Calleja and hiring Luis Garcia as coach, Villareal came back by reappointing Calleja and quickly dismissing the latter. The Luis Garcia experience was a resounding (and predictable) failure. He managed to take out 4 points of 18 possible (4 draws and 3 defeats) a 19thfinish in La Liga. The former coach achieved the feat of leaving the club in a much worse state than he found it. Luis Garcia has done very little, managed almost nothing. The worst part of all this is that you can’t really blame him, because of the horrible situation of the Valencian club. A staff crumbling under the weight of key players departures, injuries, a workforce squandered by the management of the past, a board particularly unable to replace their best elements ewith new talented ones. The very definition of the guy in the wrong place at the wrong time.

The last time that Villareal found themselves in the relegation zone was at the end of the 2011/12 campaign,when they were relegated. Now we’re in February and the yellow submarine seems at the bottom of the sea.

The good

The Valencian club has several technical players the likes of Manu Trigueros a midfielder who play like Daniel Parejo, he is even better at passing he has 87.6% of precision per game while Parejo has 85% they both play as central midfielder in a flat 4-4-2, Pablo Fornals a fresh young Spaniard international, he offered variants possibilities to combining in the final third; Santiago Caseres, a former Boca Juniors defensive midfielder, despite being an aggressive he is very good at passing (90.6 % pass accuracy the highest percentage of the club), Alfonso Pedraza who assisted three times yet. These men are the main responsible of Villareal’s 80.4% passes completed. However, they have only 49.4% average possession.

Sergio Asenjo (29 years-old) has been under heavy fire this season (15.5 shots conceded per match) and despite making the 2ndmost saves in the league, 94, his team is 19th. Which brings the question, could it have been even worse with another keeper?

Against Barcelona, the Super Eagle winger Samuel Chukweueze was the most fouled Villareal player, winning three fouls, the same number won by Barcelona Captain Lionel Messi and completed team-high five take-on. The rise of the Nigerian is a serious element now, with 12 appearances in La Liga games.

Barcelona Villarreal Tactical Analysis
Standard Villarreal tactic when moving forward. Chukwueze cuts inside, freeing up space for Gaspar to overlap. Since all midfielders crowd him in, the left side also gets some freedom.

He was good vs Real Madrid in a 2-2 draw saved by the iconic Santi Cazorla, the former Arsenal midfielder has been decisive in 6 of his 19 appearances in La Liga with 3 goals and 4 assists. He’s the team technical leader, despite being 34 his pass accuracy is 85.9%.

The club managed 23 goals, they are 6that shooting on target with 4.6 shots on target per game for a total of 101 shots. The team creates chances though individual skills. Despite finding the target often they are only 16thin the Spanish first division at scoring only 1 goal per match the fact that they don’t give up on taking a lot of shots means that one day it would work if their continue. According to they are better in Europa league, on average 5.3 among 16.3 shots per game are on target, while in La Liga they got 13.6 shot per game with 4.6 on target.

The bad

Usually, the Yellow Submarine set-up in a flat 4-4-2 shape with the front line composed by Gerard Moreno, Carlos Bacca and Karl Toko Ekambi. The first one scored 4 goals in 22 games, Carlos Bacca who managed 15 goals last season has only scored four times this campaign and the latter scored three times. In total the three men have scored 11, Christian Stuani has scored more than them – such statistics that show how inefficient are the strikers.

When you remind that this club had some world-class strikers in the past: the veteran Sonny Anderson in 2003, Martin Palermo, Diego Forlan who under Manuel Pellegrini (2004-2009) was turned into one of the most Spain’s most potent strikers. Ending his first season as the joint top scorer with Samuel Eto’o on 25 goals. Forlan went to Atletico Madrid, they relied on Nihat Kavheci and Guillermo Franco. Then the Italian Giuseppe Rossi came and scored 29 goals in the 2010/11 campaign (18 in la Liga, 11 in Europaleague). The last one was Cedric Bakambu who scored 12 and 11 goals respectively in 2015/16 and 2017/18 campaigns, it was less than the formers but he brought a serious physical presence in the penalty box. He was fast and able to use his two feet but he couldn’t resist to the Chinese’s sirens.

Another notable fact is discipline. The yellow submarine in 40 appearances, all competitions includes saw yellow 80 times, and red 4 times. On average 2 yellow cards per game. As we can see on the image below

Villarreal LaLiga Tactical Analysis


On 24 players used in la Liga, only 3 haven’t bookmarked yet. Sergio Asenjo the keeper, and the wingers Chukwueze and Daniel Raba. Mario Gaspar lead the way with 8 yellow cards and a red, Ramiro Funes Mori and Alvaro Gonzales follow him with both 7 yellow cards and a red for the latter; Jaume Costa completed the podium with 6. It’s the result of their 17.9 tackles per game and 13.7 fouls committed par game.

Villareal apply a high pressure when it doesn’t work, they commit fouls to stop the opponent attacking.

Villarreal LaLiga Tactical Analysis
A man-marking set-up to counter the Valencia 4-4-2 shape


Villarreal LaLiga Tactical Analysis
Villarreal would press when out of possession and play through the wings when attacking.

The yellow submarine have not won a single LaLiga Santander fixture since 25 November and they are facing the serious threat of relegation from the Spanish top flight.

And the transfer moves

The first contributor to this decline is – for once, their transfer policy had failed and players were not adequately replaced. The club can’t get on a shred transfer strategy but they can do better. Sacking a manager after only 50 days of work is ridiculous, especially when they haven’t strengthened enough the squad in the winter market (which they obviously need to do). Unexpected and risky more.

A decade ago, the scouting network was superb in attracting a variety of talents. In the first wave we had: Pepe Reina form Barcelona, Jose Mari from Milan AC, Fabricio Coloccini on a season loan in 2003, Juan Roman Riquelme, the jewel in the crown, and the club legend Marcos Senna came across the Atlantic from Brazilian club Associacao Deportivo Sao Caetano.

The club doesn’t follow the transfer market, buying low-cost players, developing them and reselling them at good prices as recent examples: Samu Castillejo, Cedric Bakambu, and Rodri. Sportingly, Villareal have no access anymore to the Champions League, an important sources of revenues for a small club.

During the winter break, many of those who failed left the club: Miguel Layun (Monterrey), Manuel Iturra (Maccabi Haifa), Ruben Semedo (Rio Ave)  Roberto Soriano and Nicola Sansone both went to Bologna on loan while Vicente de la Fuente Iborra came from Leicester. The latter was a former Levante and Sevilla player, he used to play behind the striker, his aerial presence would be helpful.


Despite struggling, the president Fernando Roig invests €10 million per year on youth development. With one of the most potent academies in Spanish football, there won’t be much for Villareal supporters to worry about regarding their club’s long term future. Luis Garcia was fired because the easy answer to any bad sports result is the automatic dismissal of the coach. But the problem of Villareal was not him, but rather an inefficient and destructive team-building strategy, resembling a sandcastle inevitably overturned and rebuilt in the hope that there will be a solid foundation. If Calleja transforms the team into a more efficient winning machine within the 16 yards, the remontadais possible. However is he able to? Let’s wait and hope!